Showing posts with label Procol Harum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Procol Harum. Show all posts

Monday, June 12, 2023

Procol Harum - In Concert with the Edmonton Symphony Orchestra (1972)

Dan:

Having achieved great success with their first five albums, Procol Harum went on a North American tour with the thought of recording a live album. Having a full symphony with choir backing the sextet was a mutual interest of the Edmonton Symphony's music directors and Gary Brooker. So they went for it and made history. No symphony orchestra album ever went gold and platinum before (or maybe since?). 

Recorded in November 1971, the Edmonton concert was released on LP the following year. I immediately picked it up and played it frequently. Side 1 includes four of the band's best songs: "Conquistador," "Whaling Stories," "A Salty Dog," and "All This and More." Side 2 consists solely of the suite "In Held 'Twas in I" from Shine on Brightly. The biggest hits (e.g., "A Whiter Shade of Pale" and "Homburg") were excluded in favor of the longer narrative songs. Reportedly, the album contained a few "fixes," enabled by a second performance that was further justified by the warm audience reception. The fixes are not audible in the released version.

The results are fascinating. The orchestra and choir are not a constant presence, but Brooker's arrangements help to augment the music, making it more dramatic. Distressing songs are made more distressing, and the climax of "Grand Finale" is made grander and more climactic. 

It's tempting to compare Edmonton with the Moody Blues' Days of Future Passed since both include symphony orchestras. But Edmonton is a live concert, and Days is a studio album, and that makes any comparisons superficial at best. However, both albums demonstrate how far early prog bands were willing to go in their efforts to transcend ordinary rock and roll. The group Renaissance were clearly encouraged by these earlier efforts in performing their Live at Carnegie Hall concert, released on record in 1976. Rennaissance were to follow with a similar concert at the Royal Albert Hall in 1977.

Procol Harum's In Concert with the Edmonton Symphony Orchestra also stands apart from all prog+symphony collaborations because their dark narratives are unlikely choices to perform symphonically. Songs about shipwrecks, madness, and tarnished conquerors encapsulate Procol Harum's legacy, and it's to the band's credit that such material could not only survive the symphonic treatment but also flourish. 

Steve:

It made total sense for Procol Harum to perform live with an orchestra, and it made just as much sense to release it as a live album. It did not surprise me at all to learn that Gary Brooker wrote the arrangements himself; he'd already proven to be a very skilled orchestrator with the title track to A Salty Dog, which is naturally included here. Two other epic Procol favorites of mine are also included. "Whaling Stories" and "In Held 'Twas in I" are the centerpieces of a very strong track list. Oddly, their newest album, Broken Barricades, is the only studio album not represented in the set. This omission was rectified with the expanded CD version, which adds two excellent tracks from Barricades: "Luskus Delph" and "Simple Sister".  

While I still don't enjoy any of these versions quite as much as their studio equivalents, Gary Brooker's singing never sounded better than it does here, and the live sound was recorded very well, with the rock band and orchestra working together rather than fighting for space in the mix. I definitely miss the presence of Robin Trower, who had recently left the band for a lucrative solo career, and who is replaced here by Dave Ball, his only appearance on a Procol Harum album. Ball delivers a workmanlike, restrained performance, rightfully ceding the focus to the orchestral colors and to Brooker's vocal and piano stylings. The album loses some of the chemistry that made the band's early studio albums so exciting, but overall, the presentation of these expanded orchestral visions of classic tracks makes it worth the sacrifice. 

Monday, May 15, 2023

Procol Harum - Shine on Brightly (1968)

Steve:

In our earlier post about Procol Harum's self-titled debut album, I mentioned that the albums immediately following the debut were the ones I identified with the most. Of those, Shine on Brightly is my favorite, hands down, and a treasured album that I know by heart, listen to often, and would most likely place on an all-time-favorites list. On this album, guitarist Robin Trower gets a bit more space to play his expressive leads, and the band experiments with song structures that match the literary ambitions of the lyrics -- the beginning of prog as we know it!

The first 2 1/2 songs follow the template of the debut album - tuneful & concise songs driven by Procol Harum's unique piano/organ mixture, Gary Brooker's rich vocals, and Keith Reid's striking lyrical themes. Where these songs depart from the debut album's template lies in Robin Trower's increased presence; in between the vocal lines, his thickly distorted guitar interjects similarly to Eric Clapton's playing on the Cream albums. This adds to the music's weight and introduces a new melodic element to enhance the already colorful songwriting.  

At the midpoint of the third song, "Skip Softly (My Moonbeams)", things start to get strange. The first half of the song was a fun, whimsical oom-pah oom-pah music hall number (albeit with howling lead guitar), but a transitional section leads it down into a completely different, darker space. The remainder of the song (all instrumental) goes from moody, dark ambience to a one-note guitar solo, a false ending, then a sudden jump into a super-fast coda that sounds like circus music at 45 RPM. This is a hint that this album is trying out new stuff. From there, even relatively straight songs are delivered in ways the band hadn't shown us before: "Wish Me Well" is a straight blues tune turned psychedelic thanks to Trower's wailing guitar, and "Magdalene (My Regal Zonophone)" avoids rock entirely in favor of a church chorale arrangement.

The tour-de force takes up most of side 2 and is arguably the first multi-part progressive rock epic: "In Held Twas in I". This was the first song I remember hearing by Procol Harum - Dan must have had a copy of it on tape, and at a young age I was mystified by it. The suite's title is an acrostic: it was derived by stringing together the first word from each section of the piece. It begins with a long spooky narration and goes through several very different sections to a climactic conclusion with choir (pre-Atom Heart Mother!) in about 17 minutes. It's the perfect capper to a near-perfect album.

Dan:

I remember getting this album when it came out, just about the time Steve was born. It must have been the LP he heard at a very early age since I didn't have any taping equipment and CDs were to follow more than 10 years later. I love "In Held Twas in I," which begins with the recitation "In the darkness of the night only occasionally relieved by glimpses of Nirvana..." and ends with the Dalai Lama's advice to the seeker of the meaning of life. "Well, my son, life is like a beanstalk, isn't it?" Other phrases from this opening narrative, such as "wallowing in a morass of self-despair made only more painful by the knowledge that all I am is of my own making," still drift into my mind at odd times. 

"In Held" also contains a second narration that is more cryptically disturbing than humorous. And the part of the suite titled "Autumn of My Madness" lays it out expressly as the troubled lyrics perfectly match the anguished chords. The title track is also about madness. This obviously dark foreboding appears often in Procol Harum's recordings. Hey, this is the band that wrote about shipwrecks! 

Friday, May 12, 2023

Procol Harum - Procol Harum

Dan:

I used to hear "Whiter Shade of Pale" a lot during the late 1960s. It was released in 1967 as a single. The UK album with the iconic cover art actually omitted the hit single. Fortunately for album buyers, the US version led off with "Whiter Shade." I never really owned the record; it was not a priority because it was played so often on the radio. It's one of those songs that I never tire of hearing, even 50+ years later. It sealed its place in rock history when chosen for The Big Chill's soundtrack in 1983. 

As many critics have said, "Whiter Shade" succeeds because it's not straightforwardly interpretable, and a literal interpretation is bound to be pointless. Like the Grateful Dead's lyricist, Robert Hunter, Keith Reid leaves a certain number of "factual" clues that never seem to cohere into a specific story or scenario. That's a good thing because who wants to have everything spelled out?

Of course, the lyrics are only part of the story. Matthew Fisher's Bach-inspired Hammond organ cinches the deal that makes the four-minute song a timeless classic. 

Of all the members of Procol Harum's original lineup, I feel that guitarist Robin Trower made the biggest impact on rock music. Pictured at the top, "Robbie" is a mere six months younger than me. (I tend to relate to musicians of my own generation.) There is not much space for Trower on many of Procol Harum's songs, except for their second album Shine on Brightly. His featured instrumental, "Repent Walpurgis," closes Procol Harum with as fine a track as the band has ever recorded, IMHO. 

"Homburg," which appears on some versions of the original album and is added as a bonus on CD reissues, also deserves special mention for its cool lyrics. Although the premise of the song is easy to decipher (girl leaving boy), the lyrics remain mysterious. "The mirror, on reflection, has climbed back up on the wall" from the first verse is amazing, as is the whole second verse: 

The town clock in the market square / Stands waiting for the hour  
When its hands they both turn backward / And on meeting will devour  
Both themselves and also any fool / Who dares to tell the time  
And the sun and moon will shadow / And the signpost cease to sign.

In terms of (re-)discovery, son Steve is the one who loaned me his CD reissue of Procol Harum a few years ago. I never owned my own copy, but now I do. 

Steve:

This is indeed a very strong album by one of the finest bands of their time, and yet it struck me that although I listen to Procol Harum frequently, I don't reach for this album very often. More so than their next few albums, Procol Harum emphasizes a cohesive sound, really coloring outside the lines just once, on the music hall goof "Mabel". Future albums would see the band getting a lot heavier and more stylistically eclectic. Since that was the Procol Harum I grew up with (I got this album much later than I did the first few), that's how I identify with them. I see Procol Harum as a direct product of the literate, organ-driven school of rock music influenced by Bob Dylan circa Blonde on Blonde, along with The Band.  

Procol Harum nonetheless has some amazing highlights - "Something Following Me", "A Christmas Camel", "Conquistador" and "She Wandered Through the Garden Fence" are my favorites. "A Whiter Shade of Pale" is a perfect storm of the Three Ms (mystery, majesty, and melancholy); I have never quite understood why it was such a big hit or why it has endured so long, but it definitely sucks you in, even if I can't make heads or tails of it lyrically.

Wrap Up - Our Final Post

We've reached the end of our project, having posted joint reviews of 130 albums and including comments on many others as part of our com...