Showing posts with label 1978. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1978. Show all posts

Monday, July 24, 2023

Dire Straits - Dire Straits (1978)

Dan:

There was, perhaps, no more welcome debut in 1978 than the self-titled Dire Straits. Combining clever songs with driving rhythms and clean guitar lines, this new band made a huge impact on a wide audience. An otherwise normal colleague of mine in Florida got hooked on the hit "Sultans of Swing," and who could blame him? It remains my favorite Dire Straits song, although Brothers in Arms is my favorite Dire Straits album. 

The original band included the Knopfler Brothers (Mark and David) on guitars with John Illsley on bass and Pick Withers on the skins. Mark was the undisputed leader of Dire Straits; he wrote all the songs, played lead guitar, and sang all the songs. 

There is no special discovery story for this album. It seemed to impose itself on everyone I knew via the FM radio airplay of "Sultans." I liked the song in part because it was about a fictitious jazz group and the personal stories of its members playing to inattentive small audiences while barely being able to afford their instruments. Except perhaps Harry: 

And Harry doesn't mind, if he doesn't, make the scene 
He's got a daytime job, he's doing alright. 

Certainly not an unrealistic scenario, but who else in the rock world would think of composing such a song? Mark seemingly references brother David in the lyric: 

You check out guitar George.
He knows all the chords.
Mind, it's strictly rhythm he doesn't want to make it cry or sing. 

If I were David Knopfler, I would gladly play rhythm and let my more talented bro's axe handle the crying and singing. 

As it swept over us, Dire Straits' other songs became known as well. Many of these seem understated, lacking wild solos, bashing beats, and raucous vocals. But they're all well-crafted and attractive on the terms the Knopflers offered to listeners. My favorites are all on side 2, following "Sultans": "In the Gallery," Wild West End," and "Lions." 

Dire Straits' approach to writing and playing original songs was to last for the next four years, after which they began to stretch the length of some songs. Love Over Gold and Brothers in Arms are masterpieces that reflect a more sophisticated approach to composing while not losing their signature sound. That said, there's something fresh and exciting about the first album that has never been bested. 

Finally, I remain ambivalent about the live albums, Alchemy (1984), which were (somewhat oddly) released separately as Part 1 and Part 2. Either the music did not translate well into stage performances, or I just liked the studio material better. Whatever, I didn't spend much time with Alchemy.

Steve:

Dire Straits' popularity at a time when punk and new wave were getting most of the press attention is an interesting phenomenon. I see Mark Knopfler and crew as a continuation of the gestalt that begat Bruce Springsteen in the US - that is, a 70s update of the lyrically deep world of Bob Dylan-inspired rock, at a time when Bob himself was interesting and unpredictable enough to capture the imagination of the popular masses - after nearly a decade of hibernation. Dylan had "come back" with some well received LPs and a fairly raucous rock tour (the "Rolling Thunder" tour) that resembled a traveling circus as much as a rock show.

Of course, both Springsteen and Dire Straits had plenty of tricks of their own to add to the Dylan inspiration. In Mark Knopfler, Dire Straits had a first-class lead guitarist clearly inspired by J.J. Cale (as was Eric Clapton at this time), who was also able to spin a disarmingly relatable lyric, sung in a humble, conversational tone of voice that resonated with audiences. "Sultans of Swing" is the best example of this approach, and it's fortunate that this was the song that they chose to represent themselves. As a nearly six-minute single, it went to the top 5 in multiple countries (as if echoing the similar success of "Like a Rolling Stone" a decade earlier). 

Even so, my favorite track on the album just may be the opener, "Down to the Waterline." With its quiet opening suggesting a peaceful night, the song then rips into a brisk but inviting groove with sly and playful lyrics regarding an evening liaison by the water with a lady friend. There's a slight element of danger present ("Policeman shines a light on my shoulder") but the overriding mood is just some randy fun, and it's easy to grin and tap your toes.

As with Dan, my favorite Dire Straits albums came later (either Making Movies or Love Over Gold for me, depending on the day), but the debut Dire Straits deserves a lot of credit and attention for being a unique album for its time. Even among its ostensible peer group - Elvis Costello and Graham Parker come to mind - Dire Straits had a cool austerity, not to mention its virtuoso instrumentalist, that stood out from the pack. 

Sunday, July 23, 2023

Robin Trower - Caravan to Midnight (1978)

Dan:

The late 1970s were a fertile period for LP shoppers. Many rock artists were in a groove to release one new album each year. New record stores popped up frequently in Miami, eager to push the burgeoning catalogs of popular artists. I remember visiting a new store (forgot the name - was it Music Makers?), which didn't last too long, but I found Caravan to Midnight by Robin Trower as I browsed. I knew who/what Robin Trower was - a guitarist and a group! I remember hearing a lot of his music from the early 1970s - classic albums such as Twice Removed from Yesterday (1972) and Bridge of Sighs (1974), but I realized that I didn't actually own any Robin Trower records. So I bought Caravan to Midnight on the spot to fill that embarrassing hole in my collection. 

I was pleasantly surprised to find the original band pretty much intact. Bill Lordan from 
Sly & The Family Stone had replaced the first drummer, Reg Isadore, beginning with For Earth Below (1975), but vocalist/bassist James Dewar remained. However, Louisiana native Rustee Allen (aka Rusty Stone, also a former member of Sly & The Family Stone) was the bassist on Caravan. 

I'm still puzzled why Robin Trower (the group) was rarely mentioned when critics wrote about power trios of the day like The Jimi Hendrix Experience, Rush, and Cream. Maybe the lack of gimmicks explains the lack of recognition. For three players without synthesizers, background vocalists, or dubbed in horn sections, Robin Trower sure filled a lot of the available ear space. Trower's guitar lines are loaded with authority, whether he's soloing or just riffing, and the rhythm players and vocals are as good as they get. 

Speaking of vocals, I've read reviews that place Dewar in the top echelon of blues-rock singers, and I wouldn't argue against that claim. His phrasing always seems to hit the spot and gives lyrics, no matter how mundane, a depth that most blues-rock vocalists don't match. However, comparing Dewar to blues artists like Buddy Guy, Muddy Waters, John Lee Hooker, and B.B. King might be a bit of a stretch, not to mention the dozens of R&B/soul singers over the past 70 years. Yes, Dewar sings better than Stevie Ray Vaughan, but not as good as Otis Redding or Sam Cooke.

A key track on Caravan to Midnight is the title piece, a 5-minute instrumental featuring Trower's sustained chords on a mid-tempo burn. It reminds me a little of David Gilmour's song "Raise My Rent" off of his 1978 solo album. For fans of straight-ahead rock, the first track, "My Love (Burning Love)" offers a satisfying taste of Trower comping behind Dewar's raw vocals. Caravan to Midnight also includes two atypical songs: "Lost in Love" and "Birthday Boy." These are both sweet and sincere, and they break up the program nicely.

My favorite tracks are "I'm Out to Get You," "Fool," "King of the Dance" - a nod to disco - and the closing "Sail On." Perhaps it's due to repeated listening over a period of 45 years, but these songs all sound perfect to me. They cover the range of styles in the group's comfort zone while moving away from earlier formulas such as the epic "Bridge of Signs/In This Place" sequence from Bridge of Signs and the hard rock of "Hannah" and "Rock Me Baby" from Twice Removed from Yesterday. Don't get me wrong, I dig the earlier albums a lot, but it's the new versatility of the band that makes Caravan to Midnight special. 

Trower continues to record. His most recent album I know of is No More Worlds to Conquer, released in 2022, and the chops are still there. As a fellow "senior citizen," just six months older than Trower, I can understand why his creative powers could be sustained past age 75. A 60-year recording career serves as a deep well of experience that can be drawn from when needed. 

Steve:

I agree with Dan's assessment that Robin Trower has received less substantive regard than befits an artist of his stature. I say "substantive" because although he is a well-regarded artist, the achievements for which he is given credit are mostly reduced to something like, "he took the baton from Jimi Hendrix circa Electric Ladyland, took it to the bank, and has been milking that ever since". While this may be true of his early albums (i.e., before any "milking" accusations would even be appropriate), Trower is rarely given credit for the stylistic growth arc I can see on his 70s albums. Far from "making the same album over and over again", Trower established his thesis on the first album (Twice Removed from Yesterday), perfected the style on his second (Bridge of Sighs), repeated himself on his third (the still fine For Earth Below), tinkered with the formula by adding soul and funk on his fourth (Long Misty Days), made a failed attempt at a new style on his fifth (the tentative In City Dreams), and corrected that album's mistakes for a shiny new look for his sixth (Caravan to Midnight). 

Caravan uses Trower's unique guitar style and sound as an identifying stamp on the songs, but the songs themselves are not based around or otherwise dependent on that sound. Songs such as "Fool", "It's for You", or "My Love (Burning Love)" could proudly stand as highlights on the albums of any number of artists; the songs are well written, thoughtfully arranged, and convey real emotion. Singer James Dewar, who co-wrote all but one of the tracks with Trower, deserves a lot of the credit for making these songs as strong and convincing as they are.

Dan clearly enjoyed this album a lot when I was a kid, as I recall it playing in the house frequently, particularly side 2, which kicks off with my favorite tune, "Fool". With their new self-assured style, diversity rules the day, as the middle of side 2 features two very unusual songs for Trower: "Birthday Boy" and "King of the Dance". The first of these is a ballad with a very striking production style: Dewar's vocals have an eerie ring-modulated effect, giving them a sad and alienated feel as he weeps through the high notes in the cathartic chorus. The latter ("King of the Dance") is its polar opposite, a triumphant romp with a danceable beat, as Dewar roars happily and Trower has fun with his wah-wah pedal.

Trower would mostly return to basics on his subsequent albums, but the gains he made on Caravan to Midnight would continue to give his work the same depth and diversity that make this one of his best achievements.

Saturday, July 22, 2023

Jeff Wayne - Jeff Wayne's Musical Version of The War of the Worlds (1978)

Steve:

I'm not sure how or why this interesting double album ended up in our house when I was a child, but it made a big impression on me. I believe Dan may have borrowed it from a friend or colleague and made a tape of it. I was not previously familiar with the H.G. Wells' novel on which it was based, but the sci-fi trope of Martians invading Earth was a well-worn premise, so it was not hard to get into or understand.  

My initial draw to the album was the singing of Justin Hayward of The Moody Blues, my favorite band at the time. Hayward appears both on the album's single "Forever Autumn" and as the singing voice of Oglivie the scientist in the album's overture, "The Eve of the War". War of the Worlds also features other celebrity voices, none of whom I knew at the time but who are familiar now: actor Richard Burton as the narrator journalist; David Essex of "Rock On" fame, as the artilleryman; Phil Lynott of Thin Lizzy as Parson Nathaniel; and Chris Thompson of Manfred Mann's Earth Band as the voice of humanity.  

Jeff Wayne, the producer and composer of this project, was a behind-the-scenes figure in British music, known mainly for composing for TV shows, commercial jingles, and producing albums by artists such as David Essex. The War of the Worlds was the first album expressly put out under his own name, and it was only a modest hit in the US (hitting #94) but a massive hit in the UK (hitting #4) and nearly inciting Martianmania in Australia where it hit #1 and went 10x platinum.

Although the album is largely driven by Burton's narrative and mood-setting instrumentals, Wayne employs several memorable motifs that recur throughout the album in a variety of contexts, giving the whole project a sense of unity. The vocal cameos by the celebrity singers are used for songs played in an energetic synth-rock/disco mode that sounds dated at times, but they have more than enough heart to compensate. Phil Lynott in particular nearly goes bananas 
in "The Spirit of Man" as the insane Parson Nathaniel, a fiery preacher who is convinced that God has abandoned humanity and sent the Martians to punish humans for their sinful ways. I only wish Thin Lizzy had released a song with this intensity (Lynott usually plays it cool as a low-key badass on Thin Lizzy albums).  

My dominant memory of this album, and one that haunts me to this day, comes from the penultimate track, "Dead London". At this time in the story, the Martians have turned Earth into a desolate wasteland. As our narrator walks through the empty streets of London, he realizes that the Martians are dying, having succumbed to the bacteria in the Earth's atmosphere to which humans have long been immune. In between the creepy narration and creepier horror-film-worthy music, the Martians let out sickly, electronically modified screams of ULLAAAAAAAA. This "Martian Voice" had occurred periodically throughout the album, sounding triumphant and even comical previously, but in this suspenseful context of anguish and pain, the voice is absolutely terrifying. I recall being so scared by this part of the album that I had trouble sleeping at night. It still makes my skin crawl thinking about it, and I rarely if ever listen to that track anymore. So beware, kids!

As a more lighthearted postscript, it was interesting to discover that a friend I had met online about 15 years ago is the cousin of one of the songwriters of "Forever Autumn", a top 5 single in the UK (sans narration), which was actually a cover of a previously released single by Vigrass & Osborne from 1972. According to Wikipedia, the song's melody was originally written by Jeff Wayne, Paul Vigrass (the cousin of my friend) and Gary Osborne in 1969 for a Lego commercial. The single was a top-20 hit in Japan. I am not making this up. Justin Hayward's version on War of the Worlds has since been included in Moody Blues anthologies and even performed live on stage by that group.

A remake of Wayne's opus was released in 2012 as Jeff Wayne's Musical Version of War of the Worlds - The New Generation, with Liam Neeson playing the part of the narrator journalist. I have not heard it yet, but perhaps I will boldly go there someday in the future.  

Dan: 

Steve and I had a lot of fun listening to this album and still joke about it today. It's fascinating to read his impressions that were stamped into him as a boy. For the "record," I borrowed the album from my university's library. As far back as the early 1960s, it was common in my experience to borrow vinyl records from libraries. I might have been the only one to check out Jeff Wayne's album because I remember few signs of wear on the vinyl surface. I probably made the tape before I returned the album to the library. Now Steve and I each have a digital version. There are times when I long for the original LP if only for the extensive illustrations and accompanying libretto. The illustration above is one of 12 included with the gatefold LP.

As a child myself, I saw the technicolor motion picture titled War of the Worlds (the 1953 version with Gene Barry, not Steven Spielberg's remake in 2005 with Tom Cruise). Wells' book was published in 1898 (all they had were books and theater in those days). The movie was indeed scary to a young boy like me, so in that respect Steve and I had similar pre-adolescent experiences. 

As for the music, I can barely listen to it without snickering. The songs lean towards corny, but there are wonderful sonic effects. If the dying Martians still scare Steve, the music on "The Red Weed" can give me chills (as long as I have not snickered too much). It's a bit of a journey to listen to all four sides in one sitting, but I have always admired the effort and skill involved in producing this novel piece of late 1970s pop art. Thanks to Steve for researching the facts surrounding the album.

Friday, July 21, 2023

Gino Vannelli - Brother to Brother (1978)

Steve:

Gino Vannelli is a Canadian soul singer who had a few hits in the late 70s and early 80s. I believe Brother to Brother was one of the many albums Dan taped off the radio back in the late 70s when Zeta-4 played complete albums every day at noon. It represents Vannelli at his creative and commercial peak; the album climbed to #13 on the US Billboard charts, and its flagship single "I Just Wanna Stop" went all the way to #4. In spite of its commercial leanings, Brother to Brother does share a trait common to other late 70s albums covered in this blog: the composing, production, and sonic detail and depth are all top notch, allowing listeners to bathe themselves in its ocean of sound, its wealth of great pop hooks, or both.

Indeed, were it not for the catchy and memorable pop songs, I may not have remembered this album as vividly as I did when I decided on a whim to purchase my own copy of Brother to Brother some 15 years ago. This decision was driven by nostalgia more than anything else, but once I put it on, I instantly remembered all these fine songs despite not having heard them in decades. I found myself returning to the album often, and as I did, the finer points of the amazing music underneath made themselves known. This is not an album that screams "Prog!" but as with Steely Dan or Toto, the musicians behind it are so supremely skilled that they can make incredibly complex music sound easy, natural, and catchy.

"Appaloosa" begins the album on a thrilling and dramatic note, punctuating a funky rock groove with tension-raising rhythmic accents, jazzy chord changes, and a climactic falsetto hook in the chorus. I remember a few years ago I was playing this song when I had some friends over, and one friend (a musician, btw) asked if it was Frank Zappa. Not quite, but he wasn't too far off the track. Although not released as a single, "Appaloosa" has earned inclusion on every "Best Of" Vannelli album I've seen thus far.

Vannelli keeps the album interesting throughout by alternating louder/faster songs and slower/romantic songs. Of the former, "Love and Emotion", "The Evil Eye", and the album's centerpiece, the 7-minute "Brother to Brother" all have prominent guitar, busy drums, and rapid chord changes, all while staying within the pop song format. "Brother to Brother" departs slightly from this formula by using multiple sections and more dramatic layers as befits a song occupying 7 minutes (although I would not call this song a "prog epic").  

The slower, more soulful songs are uniformly beautiful and memorable, and reinforce a consistent mood while all sounding distinct from each other. The big hit, "I Just Wanna Stop", is quintessential late 70s "yacht rock" (a term I use endearingly) that uses Vannelli's vocal abilities to their fullest to give added gravity to the longing, pleading lyrics. "The River Must Flow", "Feel Like Flying", "People I Belong To" and "Wheels of Life" are all equally impressive in different ways.

Although Vannelli made some fine albums prior to and after Brother to Brother, this album hits the sweet spot and gets the most plays from me by far. It's an ideal pop album in a way - the hooks reel you in, but the music keeps you interested for years to come.

Dan:

The first time I ever heard Gino Vannelli was in a house in Miami's Little Havana. I had bumped into German, one of my students, in a record store and we got talking about hi fi. He is the reason why I became an (gasp) audiophile, a dubious status that can only be self-imposed after years of listening and spending. German played a track from Vannelli's Powerful People (1974) to show off how good the recording was. His hi fi was awesome and so was the music. Thanks German!

I'm not sure when Brother to Brother entered my collection. I know I had the LP, but Steve may be right about the cassette recording too. Regardless, I dug every song on the album and played it enough so that my young son would never forget it. He's right about the album's enduring appeal.

Within the past year, I added the LP back into my collection. As a seasoned audiophile by this time, I paid attention to the recording details, especially the engineer, as well as the musicians and backing vocalists. For a mere 5 bucks, I managed to find an early pressing of a Bernie Grundman production featuring a fantastic studio ensemble. Brothers Ross and Joe Vannelli were joined by jazz luminaries Victor Feldman, Ernie Watts, Manolo Badrena, and a trio of soul-singing ladies, among others. 

As Steve notes, the songs on Brother to Brother tend to be busy and complex. In most cases I would be suspicious of "overproduction," my favorite term for mindless, cluttered, over-the-top arrangements. But with Grundman and Gino's caring touches, Brother to Brother, on vinyl at least, passes any audiophile test. And not that many audiophile faves are found amongst Vannelli's genre of all-out rock. But this one is different and holds an honored place in both Steve's and my collections. 

Thursday, July 20, 2023

The Muffins - Manna/Mirage (1978)

Steve:

Although progressive rock found its primary footing in the UK during its heyday in the 1970s, I learned in the early 90s that progressive rock had been happening all over the globe all along. In the United States, variations on the prog rock style had found commercial acceptance through bands like Styx and Kansas, although these bands were only the most visible ones. In the Washington DC area alone, bands like Happy the Man, However, and The Muffins were quietly making adventurous music that largely flew under the radar.  

The Muffins owed much of their inspiration to the Canterbury progressive rock style, taking an approach 
similar to bands such as Hatfield and the North, Henry Cow, and Soft Machine. However, their American slant also included the playful and comedic style of Frank Zappa in addition to other quintessentially American jazz influences of the time. While Manna/Mirage was their first album, the band had been honing its sound for at least four years prior, and the debut shows the band fully formed and with a clear vision and purpose.

Lacking the support of a major label contract, The Muffins took matters into their own hands, recording in their own home/studio in Rockville, Maryland, and starting their own record label, Random Radar Records, to issue albums by The Muffins and other local artists. Despite their relatively low profile, their music did not go unnoticed in the UK and Europe. Fred Frith (of Henry Cow) recruited the band to back him on half of his solo album Gravity (1980). Subsequently, Frith produced and played on the Muffins' album <185> (1980). Once the CD reissue of long out-of-print prog albums became available in the early 1990s, the locally prestigious Cuneiform label made Manna/Mirage one of its first reissues - first under the Wayside Music Archive Series rubric in 1991 (the copy I have) and under Cuneiform Records proper in 1993.

Their popularity among an international fan base has kept The Muffins sporadically active. After breaking up in the early 1980s, the band reunited in the late 1990s and continue to perform and record off and on to this day. Primary composer, keyboardist, and woodwind player Dave Newhouse remains active leading or participating in multiple other projects as well, including Manna/Mirage, Moon Men, Moon X, Diratz (with French vocalist Carla Diratz) and Hart/Newhouse.

My introduction to the Muffins was via Frith's Gravity album, which I discovered in my college's old record collection, dating from the years when the school had a student-run radio station. I got involved with a group of other students who were intent on reviving the station. Although it resulted in hours of fun and the discovery of unusual albums such as Gravity, the station itself could not generate a signal strong enough to be heard by anyone except faintly in the student dorms, and only then if listened to on a radio plugged into the dorm's electrical outlets. The noble project thus fizzled out, but I'm proud to have been a part of it.

After college, around 1992, I bought Manna/Mirage either at Tower Records in Atlanta or as one of my first purchases from Wayside Music. Either way, it fits historically into a very fruitful time of discovery for me. In recent years, I have befriended various people either in or otherwise associated with the band and its releases. It was gratifying to follow the several years it took to put together Baker's Dozen, a 12-CD plus DVD box set documenting the Muffins' history, complete with a thorough booklet, lovingly packaged and sold by Cuneiform, and released to widespread acclaim in the fall of 2022.

Dan:

I had never heard of The Muffins until Steve chose to include Manna/Mirage in our discovery blog. So I took a couple of listens to hear what I had missed for the past 45 years. Like several others of his choices that were new to me, I was pleasantly surprised. I've always favored instrumental groups because they oblige bands to create wordless images that evoke a listener's emotional and cerebral responses. That's a daunting challenge that my favorite jazz groups seem to surmount effortlessly through their preparation, skill and imagination. Groups like Soft Machine, who straddle jazz and prog, and artists like Frank Zappa, Can, and Happy the Man never seem to run out of ideas despite the absence of lyrics to guide them. 

The Muffins add to the challenge by choosing very long compositions. "Amelia Earhart" runs almost 16 minutes, and "The Adventures of Captain Boomerang" goes for 22:46! They survive the challenges by varying meters, intensities, and combinations of instruments. It's impressive how they stay together through all of these variations. Of the short tracks, I like the laid-back vibe of the opening "Monkey With the Golden Eyes." Any prog group bold enough to feature flutes and vibes gets my approval. 

Good to know that someone cared enough to produce Baker's Dozen. Bravo! 

Wednesday, July 19, 2023

Camel - Breathless (1978)

Dan:

It's hard to overstate the importance of Camel to our joint discovery of prog in 1978, despite the band's relatively obscure place in rock history. Camel is considered one of those "cult" bands, revered by a core group of dedicated fans but seemingly destined not to receive wider acclaim. But unlike other cult bands (like Love), Camel released about 30 albums in its 30 years of activity (1973-2002) many on major labels (MCA, Decca/Gama) as well as their own label (Camel Productions).

Many cult bands deserve their obscurity, and their fan base probably delights in being on the fringe. But in Camel's case, the music industry, and in turn the listening public, can be blamed for ignoring Camel's music. That's sad because there is so much wonderful music in their studio albums and live recordings. 

As I wrote in my "Father's Story" post, Camel's Breathless was a noontime album played in its entirety by a deejay in Miami. We had moved there the year before and I had acquired a cassette recorder that hooked up to my FM receiver. I taped the noontime albums on days that I worked from home. I remember the deejay scrambling to talk about Camel, a band that she had never heard of before. Her only insight was that Breathless was not Camel's first recording. Yes, those were the good old days when airplay was not always ruled by monetary criteria, allowing deejays to play music they might never have heard themselves. 

As I listened to my tape over the next few days, everything about Breathless sounded fresh and different, especially the distinctive guitar playing. But I had no idea who I was listening to. Nobody I knew had ever heard of the band. When I mentioned Camel, people figured it was Peter Frampton's band. I felt alone with secret knowledge about a great band that nobody knew existed. 

I soon found a vinyl cutout of Breathless, and it contained an inner sleeve with basic information on it. The band looked like a rather odd cast of characters. Andrew Latimer appeared to be the leader and he made the biggest impact as the only guitarist while sharing vocal duties with bassist Richard Sinclair. Peter Bardens (keyboards), Mel Collins (sax) and Andy Ward (drums) were the remaining band members. Acquiring Breathless was just the beginning of a wholly satisfying adventure into one of the world's great neglected prog bands.

My affection for Camel is directly tied to my admiration for Andrew Latimer's guitar playing. He was full of great ideas and could play with such emotion. I'd place him in the same elite company with Carlos Santana, David Gilmour, Robin Trower, and Roy Buchanan - all guitarists with the ability to speak directly to the soul of listeners - especially me. 

I didn't know at the time that Camel was in a state of constant turmoil, with band members arguing about artistic direction - some wanted to record pop singles while others wanted more extended instrumental pieces. Players left and new players came with almost every album. Camel fought with their manager and record execs about money. At one point Latimer moved to California where he started his own label. One of the albums from that time, Dust and Dreams, was allegorically based on John Steinbeck's novel The Grapes of Wrath (1939). Latimer's song "Go West" from Dust and Dreams expresses his desperation and hope for prosperity in the American west.

As a result of such conflicts, albums like Breathless are somewhat schizoid, containing different musical styles. I prefer the tunes with fewer vocals and longer instrumental sections featuring guitar. The novelty songs like "Down on the Farm" and "Wing and a Prayer" are charming enough not to spoil the album, but they certainly were never hit singles. My favorites are "Breathless," "Echoes," "Summer Lightning," and "Sleeper."

Steve:

As Dan points out, Breathless was a pivotal album in both of our musical lives. Their music was simultaneously daring/exciting and melodious/memorable, and the pop songs and moody instrumentals in their impressive catalog have an uncanny way of getting in your head and staying there. Andrew Latimer's gift is finding an emotionally resonant guitar melody and playing it with one of the finest guitar tones and techniques you'll ever hear. I count him among my "big three" favorite guitar players, along with David Gilmour and Alex Lifeson (I should probably also include Frank Zappa, but I'll keep him in a class by himself, where he'd likely prefer to reside anyway).  

Perhaps the most astonishing achievement on Breathless is its leadoff title track. I have not heard another track like it in the Camel discography, or anywhere else in music for that matter. It's a vocal-based pop song with an odd structure, sung in an impossibly pretty manner by Richard Sinclair - the giant intervals between the notes he has to hit makes it extremely difficult to sing, but he nails it. Underneath, several layered guitars sparkle like a star-filled sky for the main instrumental theme (there might even be a mandolin in there) and guide the vocal through a complex chord sequence for verses that resolve beautifully and never feel labored or awkward. The song has a dramatic pause in the middle, with Sinclair singing the last few lines of the lyric in a new melody, before a restatement of the original theme in a different key. The instrumental coda of the piece features Mel Collins' overlapping woodwinds creating billowing clouds of peaceful sound as the repeating theme fades out. Total time: four minutes of near perfection.

Although some lesser tracks fill the album (nothing rotten, though), other tracks dazzle. "Echoes" sounds at first like one of the most exciting prog instrumentals ever, until about 5 minutes in when it suddenly turns into a vocal piece. "Summer Lightning" makes tasteful use of a disco beat and grants the final three minutes to Latimer to play one of his finest guitar solos. "The Sleeper" is Breathless' closest analog to the earlier classic Camel instrumentals such as "Lunar Sea."

Speaking of classic Camel, many fans consider Breathless as a lesser album than its first few. On ProgArchives, the highest rated albums by far are three 1974-76 albums (Mirage, The Snow Goose, and Moonmadness), with Breathless and I Can See Your House from Here (1979) earning significantly lower ratings. My best explanation for this relative lack of regard is the latter two albums' inclusion of pop-like vocals, thereby distancing the band from its earlier instrumental focus, especially the all-instrumental Snow Goose.

The move towards more vocal material reflects the identity struggle within the band as personnel changed and pressure mounted to remain viable commercially. Breathless was the first and only Camel album to be released on Arista Records in the US, and the absence of a second album on that label indicates that the union did not go well. However, contrary to prevailing opinions, I believe that this period of Camel produced some of its finest music.

Tuesday, July 18, 2023

Michael Hoenig - Departure from the Northern Wasteland (1978)

Steve:

In the late 70s, electronic music was entirely new to me. I was not normally drawn to long, static instrumental soundscapes, still being in my Moody Blues/Beatles phase. I don't recall exactly when or why Dan brought this record into the house, but I remember hearing it a lot, and I was unusually fascinated by it. I still am. I found my own copy on CD in college, then got another copy on vinyl years later, and to this day I strongly believe it is the most-played album in my collection. Whenever I can't decide what to play, I just put this on. Whenever I'm exceedingly tired or depressed, I put this on. It takes me to my safe space every time, and I will never tire of it.

In retrospect, I now know that music like this was highly influenced by Tangerine Dream, who pioneered electronic music using sequencers, or synthesizers capable of playing looped repetitive figures. These repetitive figures succeed not only in freeing up melodic space for improvisation on top of the patterns, but the patterns themselves double as a rhythm machine, as their melodic loops, however complex, can repeat often enough to create an implied rhythmic pulse. 

The twenty-minute title track occupying side 1 is like a long train journey through a desolate countryside. The "northern wasteland" never changes, but there is still a strong feeling of movement felt in the music. The pulse of the wheels on the tracks puts you in a trance, and the endless tracts of land provide an infinite canvas for your thoughts. Small details catch your eye such that even a passing bird can impart a fascinating tale of its own if you follow it a while.   

Side 2 contains a similar, shorter piece called "Hanging Garden Transfer" which offers a more ebullient and fast-moving variation on the same theme. After a relatively uneventful drone with overlapping voices ("Voices of Where"), the program ends with a truly lovely piece of music, "Sun and Moon". At only four minutes long, this is an instrumental synth-based piece still using sequenced patterns, but also a discrete song structure, with implied verses, choruses, and a bridge. The lead synth voice sounds a bit like an oboe, making me think this could have been arranged for a world/jazz outfit such as Oregon and been pretty amazing in that form. It's a perfect capper to a near-perfect album and leaves me with a warm feeling in my heart.

Dan:

It warms my heart to hear that this album means so much to Steve personally. I remember that Departure from the Northern Wasteland appealed to me because at the time I was interested in electronic music. Jean-Michel Jarre, Vangelis, Terry Riley, and others made some pretty interesting albums in the 1970s and beyond. Departure was one of the best but also the most overlooked. It was Michel Hoenig's first album. I don't know much about him except that he was a very young-looking German guy who went on to make film music. That does not surprise me, given the cinematic effects like Steve's train ride that Departure evokes.

Music like this seems a little time warped. As electronics became thoroughly embedded into rock and popular music, the phrase "electronic music" lost its meaning. The way forward included new genres of techno, new age/ambient, and perhaps others. I followed the ambient trail from Eno to the present, including pioneers such as Kevin Braheny, Harold Budd, Michael Sterns, Robert Rich, and Steve Roach. None of these artists or their contemporaries (e.g., Liquid Mind, Max Corbacho) took the same approach as Michael Hoenig on Journey to the Northern Wasteland, which stands as a neglected classic rightfully situated in the history of prog. 

Wrap Up - Our Final Post

We've reached the end of our project, having posted joint reviews of 130 albums and including comments on many others as part of our com...